Protect your license and your practice with professional liability coverage built for New York counselors and LMHCs — backed by 20+ years of underwriting experience.
Counselor malpractice insurance protects counselors and therapists across New York City, Long Island and the rest of New York State. Weinsurexyz places annual policies, issues certificates of insurance quickly, and works with you directly from our office in Queens.

New York does not legally require licensed counselors to carry malpractice insurance, but insurance panel credentialing, employer requirements, and telehealth platforms almost universally require proof of coverage. Industry claims data has put the average total cost of a malpractice lawsuit against a counselor at roughly $157,000 — a real financial exposure even when the underlying claim is ultimately unfounded.
Get covered today. Individual and practice policies, occurrence-based, legal defense included.
Get a Quote or call 888-540-7374
Do counselors need malpractice insurance in New York?
Not by state law, but panel credentialing, employer policy gaps, and telehealth practice requirements make it a practical necessity for most licensed counselors and therapists.
Does coverage include telehealth?
Telehealth services should be explicitly included in your policy, subject to your scope of practice and applicable telehealth regulations. Confirm this is stated clearly before assuming it’s covered.
Misconduct complaints
Counselor and therapist misconduct complaints go through NYSED’s Office of Professional Discipline (OPD). Complaints must be submitted in writing. A malpractice lawsuit and a licensing board complaint are separate processes — the latter can affect your license independent of any lawsuit.
What does counselor malpractice insurance cover?
- Professional liability: $1,000,000 per claim / $3,000,000 annual aggregate
- Occurrence-based — no tail coverage needed
- Legal defense costs paid regardless of outcome, and they do not reduce your liability limit
- Licensure defense expenses: up to $25,000 aggregate
- Subpoena assistance: up to $10,000 annual aggregate
Individual vs. business policy
A business/practice policy fits if you own a group practice, operate as an LLC/S-corp, or have employees. Otherwise, an individual policy is right for you.
How much does counselor malpractice insurance cost in New York?
There is no single price for counselor malpractice insurance. Carriers set your premium based on your risk, and New York rates differ by region. The main factors are:
- Your profession and scope of practice
- The limits you choose (for example $1M/$3M)
- Whether you are employed, self-employed or both
- Full-time or part-time hours
- Your claims history
- Add-ons such as general liability or a business policy
The fastest way to know your cost is a quote based on your actual practice. We compare the programs we are appointed with and explain the differences in plain English.
How to get counselor malpractice insurance
- Gather your details — license or certification, the services you provide, and any prior policy or claims history.
- Choose your coverage — individual or business policy, the limits your employer, facility or contract requires, and any add-ons.
- Request a quote online or call 888-540-7374.
- Bind your policy — policies are written for one year, and we send your certificate of insurance as soon as coverage is in place.
New York resources for counselors and therapists
- NYSED Office of the Professions (licensing and discipline)
- NYS Department of Financial Services (insurance regulator)
Counselor malpractice insurance: HPSO vs. CM&F coverage
Weinsurexyz is an appointed broker for both HPSO and CM&F Group, the two largest national programs for individual healthcare providers. That means we can compare both programs’ counselor malpractice insurance for counselors and therapists and place the one that fits you best. Here is how their standard individual policies compare:
Did you know? According to HPSO and CNA claim reports, the average total cost of a malpractice lawsuit against a counselor is $157,492 — far more than a policy costs.
| Coverage | HPSO | CM&F Group |
|---|---|---|
| Professional liability limits | $1 million per claim / $3 million aggregate | $1 million per claim / $6 million aggregate |
| License defense | Up to $25,000 | Up to $35,000 per claim / $100,000 aggregate, including Medicare/Medicaid billing proceedings |
| Deposition or subpoena help | Up to $10,000 | Up to $25,000 |
| First aid expenses | Up to $10,000 | Up to $25,000 |
| Medical payments to others | Up to $25,000 per person / $100,000 aggregate | Up to $25,000 per claim / $100,000 aggregate |
| Assault on you at or commuting to work | Up to $25,000 | Included |
| Policy form | Occurrence | Occurrence |
Also included with HPSO: reimbursement for lost wages and travel when you must attend a trial or hearing (up to $1,000 a day, $25,000 total), personal and advertising injury coverage, and HIPAA breach-notification and media-expense benefits.
Also included with CM&F: full consent to settle (no claim is settled without your approval), Good Samaritan coverage for emergency care you give off the job, and 24/7 portable coverage for full-time, part-time, per diem, locum, moonlighting and volunteer work.
Both programs’ counselor malpractice insurance includes telehealth within your scope of practice and coverage that follows you when you change jobs. Details are as published by each program; limits and coverages vary by profession and state, and some coverages are not available in New York.
Coverage is subject to the terms, conditions and exclusions of the issued policy and to underwriting approval. Rates, limits and coverages vary by profession and employment status.
Frequently asked questions
Is professional liability insurance the same as malpractice insurance?
Yes. For healthcare professionals, professional liability insurance and malpractice insurance mean the same thing: coverage for claims that your professional services caused harm, including legal defense, settlements and judgments. For counselors and therapists, counselor malpractice insurance is what responds when a patient or client says your services caused harm.
Do counselors need malpractice insurance in New York?
Not by state law, but panel credentialing and most employer/practice requirements make it a practical necessity.
Is telehealth counseling covered?
Yes, when explicitly included in your policy — confirm coverage details rather than assuming.
What’s the difference between occurrence and claims-made coverage?
Occurrence covers incidents from the policy period regardless of when the claim is filed; claims-made requires separately purchased tail coverage if the policy lapses.
What’s the difference between a malpractice lawsuit and a licensing board complaint?
A malpractice lawsuit is a civil claim handled through insurance and the courts. A licensing board complaint is a separate process handled by NYSED’s Office of Professional Discipline and can affect your license independent of any lawsuit.
Why get your coverage through Weinsurexyz?
Weinsurexyz is appointed to write the same national healthcare liability programs used by HPSO and CM&F Group, backed by 20+ years of underwriting and risk management experience. Weinsurexyz is a division of Liability Advisors Inc., licensed in New York (License #1810943).
Get covered today. Individual and practice policies, occurrence-based, legal defense included.
Get a Quote or call 888-540-7374
